Discussion about this post

User's avatar
WhyNotThink's avatar

Normally I wouldn't even write about A.I. because this site is more about linguistics than technology. But this was an email from Substack, so I figured that everyone coming to my site, would have read it, all the Substack people that is.

I freely admit that AI is a force and we don't know how it will hit us. (Well, we do; it is already happening since Cambridge Analytica in 2016.) These are social media memes that people shout, but I don't think anyone really knows what it is. I was talking with a programmer yesterday, and he was explaining Algorithms in that you can ask data for specific facts, like "who wears orange hats", or some such nonsense.

Even he spoke of AI "approaching consciousness", which, who knows what that means???

Will it do or say something that has never been said or thought of before? On what basis? does it have "whims". I think a lot of people debate "what is consciousness", almost as unknowingly as speaking of AI. Consciousness is a big topic, in that some day there might be a post about it here, from me or others.

One thing about consciousness, it must be empty, until you fill it up, with all your thoughts, beliefs, memories and conjectures. After all that; IS THERE A WAY TO EMPTY IT? Or does it just get more and more full?

.

Expand full comment
Martha Nichols's avatar

This line sticks with me: "So we are left with A.I. as an 'intelligence' that can never get out of the past tense." Oh, yes. So, I'm concerned about the implications of that. We're constantly moving forward based on the past — but sometimes we have to break with the past, rebel against it, go somewhere new. I'm afraid we'll be reduced to a giant library of past impulses and mistakes and formulaic constructions of problems, that this will come to seem the norm. I think a year of ChatGPT has already shoved us in a direction tech was already pushing us in via the web and social media: reducing writing to information processing. I refuse to be limited in that way, but it doesn't mean I won't be in any case. Still, the refusing and resisting matters for me and my writing.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts